Jun 28 2009
David Maclean proves need for reform of Parliament
The Conservative Penrith and the Border MP David Maclean is to step down at the next General Election because his multiple sclerosis has worsened this year. The MP was taken by ambulance this week with the support of two medics to vote for a new Commons Speaker following what he described as the worst exacerbation yet of his illness.
His dedication to Parliament is obviously incredible, there was no need for him to attend the vote beyond his dedication, and despite his role in trying to exempt MP’s expenses from the Freedom of Information Act it is certain Parliament will be a lesser place without him and his experience. A former officer in the 51st Highland Volunteers, he was elected in 1983 and his Parliamentary career included a stint as chief whip and ministerial posts in Agriculture, the Environment and Home Office. He turned down a Cabinet role in 1995 and was diagnosed with MS in 1996.
But Maclean’s decision to step down because benefits of treatment - which will increase his quality of life and expected lifespan - would be cancelled out if he continued an MP’s workload, shows in part how Parliament needs reform beyond what others are considering. Parliament benefits from having a diverse range of Members with diverse experience; but requiring attendance to vote and having MP’s act as uber-councillors/social workers puts many off and - in Maclean’s case - out.
Why can’t MP’s vote by proxy or by electronic means, as they can in Scotland?
Why do MP’s work as uber-councillors?
Maclean said his constituency – the largest in England – deserved an MP who could go at it “full pelt”. But if we have a system where only those with the time, inclination and - in this case - physical ability to attend all the odd-hours Parliament works and act as uber-councillor “full pelt”, the pool of interested applicants is greatly reduced. You’re ruling out anyone with kids really, especially women or single parents, anyone with a health issue…
What we need is MP’s to be MP’s - scrutinising laws, representing us and holding the executive to account. Axe the uber-councillor stuff, set normal hours and let MP’s vote from elsewhere by remote and suddenly being an MP will become compatible with being a normal person - doing the school run, having a family and social life beyond work, having health issues - and we may just then get such normal people.









